This is a classic that I’m sure most maths teachers will know. I’m just hoping my Year 9 class won’t have seen it when I try it on them next week as part of a probability lesson.
In looking for some images I came across an on-line survey that Transum had done following an enquiry from a TV show. The results were interesting and worthy of a few minutes of discussion in class once the “trick” itself has been revealed.
If you haven’t seen this before, you essentially ask the following questions (respondents keep the answers in their heads):
The first part uses the fact that the sum of digits of multiples of nine is always 9, so that you always end up with a 4 which then turns into D. Most people think of Denmark and then Elephant, but not everyone does as demonstrated by the results of Transum’s online survey.
This is a nice intro to Tree Diagrams but also gives some scope for discussion of these figures, i.e.
- What’s the overall % of people that this trick works on?
- 68% seems low – would it be higher if it was a UK only audience? (rather than a global Internet audience)
- What were the percentages in our class?
- What percentage of people does it need to work on to have the desired effect in the room?
You could even follow this up with a homework to survey 10 people. Just don’t call it the “Elephant in Denmark trick” as my son did. Oh dear…
I’ve always felt that secure knowledge of times tables at Year 7 is so important simply because it gives kids the confidence to engage in so many maths topics covered in that year. As such any opportunity to practice is good even when it is in a simple game like this.
A Simple Factors and Multiples Team Game for 3-4 players
I came up with this idea whilst playing the traditional Happy Families card game with my family when on holiday. Kids seem to love this game – could I create a maths game as engaging?
I’ve tried this several times with Year 7 classes, playing in teams of 3 or 4 and they love it.
It takes very little preparation or explanation – in fact the students make the resources themselves!
You need a set of 36 blank cards for each team. Anything will do. I spent about 10 minutes furious chopping on the guillotine for 7 teams, getting 12 cards out of each A4 sheet, so 3 sheets per team, 21 sheets in all.
The learning starts by getting the teams to create their cards using the following instructions:
1, Arrange your cards into 4 columns by 9 rows
2, You need to write the first 4 multiples of each number 2 to 10 so that every card has a number on it.
I put the 36 blank cards and the above on a slip of paper in an envelope and gave an envelope to each team. With a bit of discussion within the teams, they worked out what they needed to do, but if you feel the task needs a bit more scaffolding you could use this diagram:
Once each team has their cards laid out on the table, they can start playing.
- Shuffle the cards and deal them all out.
- The objective is to collect “families” of numbers, e.g. 3,6,9,12 is the 3 family. The player with the most families wins.
- Play starts with the first player asking one of the other players (they decide who) for a particular card, e.g. “Natasha, do you have a 5?” If Natasha has that card, she must hand it over. The first player can ask again (again, they can chose any player). If the answer is no, play moves on to the next player.
- When a player has a family they must lay it face up on the table.
- Play continues until all the cards are gone – it’s that simple!